Darker Projects Productions is one of the longest running audio drama companies in modern times. Although their copyright notice is set for 2008, I have been listening to their audio dramas for upwards of five years now. DP began with mostly fan fiction, Doctor Who and Star Trek, but branched out to a series of original audio dramas, mostly with a mature theme.Website
The Darker Projects website is very nicely designed. It has easy links to their original shows, some of their fan fiction they call "devoted drama" and some behind the scenes links. In the middle column they present more detailed information on what DP is and what shows are currently released. On the right hand side is a widget that plays snippets of introduction from various cast members of DP as you first go to the show. This I find a detriment, as there's little more annoying for a regular peruser of a website than having to listen to another 20 second sound bite of welcome every time you come to a site. I recommend having it turned off, unless people want to click on it and play it. I went to Darker Projects once at work to see if a new Byron's Chronicles was released and my co-workers all had a great laugh at my expense.
Along the top is also the usual suspects of forums, contributions, about, and a complete listing of their projects. This presents another issue I have. Their listing isn't complete. I know, for example they did have a great series called "Section 31", but it's no longer featured. Rating 4/5
Audio Drama Type- Modern Theater, Fan Fiction
Darker Projects uses all the facets that have become modern theater for podcasts- a distributed network of writers, actors, and producers. Legend has it, that Darker Projects grew out of a group of friends who loved writing Star Trek fan fiction and decided to start making their own.
Acting Type- Long Distance Amateurs
While they have some of the more familiar names like Mark Kalita, David Ault and Mark Bruzee as regulars, the cast appear to be all amateur actors of varying talents. Darker Projects tends to get the best out of their actors, but sometimes those actors don't have a lot to give. For the most part, they are well cast, and give interesting reads. The most challenging issue is getting long distance actors to be able to sound like they are playing off of each other realistically. One can not fault DP for not being able to pull this off consistently. Professional actors who rarely sit in the studio at the same time for animated shows also react poorly. This is a limitation of the style. The shows all vary in acting quality, but as a general indicator I give DP a Rating 4/5 here.
Production Types- Detail Oriented
Production is one of DP's great strengths. Their shows have rich sound effects and music that is not only effective but inspiring. Detail includes layered background sounds that enhance the setting. Enhanced setting creates mood. Deeply developed production sound can often translate the tone of the author as well, and DP does this with many of its productions. I'm going to go ahead and credit Chris Snyder for setting what I consider to be the bar for some of the best audio production of amateur production features on the Internet. While there are a growing group of people who have emerged to match his prowess, there are few that seem to surpass it in the amateur realm. Rating 5/5
Writing
The writing in Darker Projects depends mostly upon the series. There are some very gripping episodes of The Falcon Banner by Christopher Patrick Lydon and some wince-worthy writing from a few shows in the anthology series Five Minute Fears. It would be unfair to give an over all writing rating here. So look for future reviews of series, and then eventually (hopefully) individual releases.
Additional Notes: Delays
I've said that Dream Realm Enterprises is the worst show I know for delays, but I'm officially calling this "The Darker Project Syndrome" for future reviews. While DRE Gold may be caught up because of lack of time, DP seems to take cruel pleasure in making its listeners wait while they are distracted by "shiny keys". A fantastic series can wait months, even over a year while producers dally in one project after another. As a listener there are few things that are more maddening than being kept in the dark for releases. I know that most listeners won't mind if they have to wait two weeks, one month, or even three months for a new release if they are given- up front- the schedules for release. I've wandered in and out of Darker Projects realm simply because frustration has caused me to go elsewhere. But I am a man of faith, in that I keep coming back to DP hoping they have not forgot me, their listener, as they play in different corners of their yard.
Over All Rating
I have only one other criticism of Darker Projects, and that is their name. "Darker" than what? Than other podcasts? I can think of at least three podcasts that have equal or darker shows in similar genres. Some of the snippet actors' comments on their opening widget may give a clue. I get the feeling that DP is pretty clear within its own circles that they produce the best audio drama on the web.
Hubris notwithstanding, they do have a great sound, and often entertain. I recommend giving them a listen if you like genre fiction- especially horror and science fiction. They haven't branched out much past those two segments, but what they do, they do quite well. Not the best, but certainly up there. Rating 4/5

I think for the "Darker" label, you have to look back at their origins. This is just a guess, but when they started out they were looking to differentiate themselves from people doing normal Trek stories and other more optimistic types of fan-shows. Section 31 is clearly meant to be a darker take on Trek's setting, and I believe it was their flagship show.
ReplyDeleteThe label is meaningless now, since as you point out there's much (MUCH!) darker stuff being done out there by different groups, but we should probably cut them some slack since they were one of the first of their kind.
I totally agree with you about their lack of focus, Star Trek Lost Frontier was looking to be a great show, and even had top billing on iTunes, but then they just stopped releasing them. When it came back, it had turned into the Section 31 reunion show, which was nice, but for all those people who never heard Section 31 (like say the majority of people who found them through iTunes) it was now a case of "who is this, and why should I care?" Now it's on hiatus again, and lord knows what it will be like when it comes back...again. (Especially since it has a new writer.
DP was and is the "sound" to beat in terms of audio quality, and I agree with you on their acting, but their lack of consistent focus just kills my interest in following their shows. Why should I start listening to something when I never know if it will be finished? (Or even continue!
Look in the vaults-
ReplyDeletehttp://darkerprojects.com/vault.php
for Section 31
http://darkerprojects.com/section31.php
Good review!
Thanks for the background Robyn! It's interesting to know what's going on behind the scenes. I wonder what Darker Projects response is to the frustration of their listeners? Have they ever given a reply?
ReplyDeleteThanks too for the correction in your blog. The response has been genuine, and that's what I had hoped for.
Warmly,
~J. Snowe
Thanks Bill... That certainly helps. I'll see if I can pull all those shows and listen to them again. I think I missed a couple in the middle :)
ReplyDeleteWarmly,
~J. Snowe
Much as it annoys me as well- one has to remember that people are doing this for free in their spare time- and the collection of lines, the time in real life to do this and well-life getting in the way of art all play a role.
ReplyDeleteThat said- DP's line is usually-they produce high qual shows and release when ready-which can indeed be a long while-much to the frustration of listeners.
I guess I have to say that this review is pretty much "right on".
ReplyDeleteI love DP and I love their original shows. I don't get into the fan fic...but if anyone were ever to "turn me" on this particular preference than it would be DP.
You pretty much nailed it on the frustration factor.... not even a whimper of an impending schedule until it's already down the pike. Yet we all always go back. It's that good.
Since they are a free show ..it seems out of my pay grade to complain too much about long spells between releases.
If it were a paying site, though, than I'm afraid it would doom them.
Excellent points Redwillie97.
ReplyDeleteI struggle with this all the time. Because it's free, should we not care?
I remember my time doing volunteer work, when my supervisor pointed out, "Just because this is volunteer, does it mean that anyone should expect anything buy your best?"
I had to agree.