Pendant Audio Productions is the "other" long running audio drama company (along with Darker Projects) that began with fan fiction and grew outwards into much more fan fiction and original tales. Pendant has been operating since 2005 with another Star Trek fanfic series called Star Trek: Defiant and then expanded outwards with a mass of shows based on DC Heroes. Many of the shows are written by Jeffrey Bridges who acts as Executive Producer over the entire prodigious production company. They have currently one hundred and sixty-three episodes released all told. Themes go from general rating to mature.
Website
Initially the website looks confusing, but in actual fact it is easy to navigate, and contains a pile of interesting information. The many shows are listed down the left side with original podcasts first. Top right hand corner of the page includes the main credits, and this is consistent if you click to the different shows. On the main page down the center are news items and release dates. This is really handy, and other productions should take note. If there's one thing I'd like to know from my favorite audio drama series is when the next episode is coming out. What makes this especially compelling is to my memory they've almost always hit their deadline- an impossible task for most other companies.
The website is built for a community. There are casting calls, information about awards presented and a link to a chat site. Everything about this site says Pendant is serious about their productions and their shows. The design is arty, but doesn't come across as too amateur.
Rating 4/5
Audio Drama Type- Modern Theater, Fan Fiction
Pendant follows all the structures of modern podcasting and in fact has a history of innovating them. While I'm certain to be corrected, Pendant is one of the first shows I know of, which used multiple podcast streams. They use sound effects and music, both theme and mood in their productions. They appear, again like Darker Projects, to have grown from a series of friends who wanted to write and produce together. These are some of the best kinds of collaboration opportunities around.
Acting Type- Long Distance Amateurs
The quality of acting ranges from okay to poor. While I'm only going to give a brief overview now (I'll do more detailed reviews of shows when I get through the companies), it's important to provide some examples. There are some excellent exceptions. In Superman, Last Son of Krypton, Kathryn Pryde as Wonder Girl has a stellar range, and Ryan H. Nelson does an able job as the Man of Steel. Jerry Scullion does an incredibly Harrison Ford impression, and that usually is phenomenal to hear. But sometimes the urge to sound like the actor can overpower the actual performance of "Indiana" and it's important that the integrity of the character takes precedent over "sound-a-likes". The biggest concern I have however is the lack of tension in much of the acting. That could be a fault of the Direction though.
Rating 2/5
Production Types- A Little Minimal But Not By Design
This is one of my biggest complaints and the cause of my love/hate relationship with Pendant. After five years of steady production, you'd think they would be further ahead in their sound. While Darker Projects, Wormwood, and Broken Sea have created compelling and sometimes entrancing sound worlds with their productions that draw you in, Pendant remains tinny and still sounding artificial. They have improved since their first episodes, but they still seem to be plagued with a very amateur sound. Their original shows, especially Dixie Stenberg with its older sound and their anthology Seminar certainly are better than many of their superhero fiction which I've been listening more too right now. Again, I'm certainly lumping many shows together in saying this, but this is an overview of what I've heard.
When it comes to dialog, the voice recordings are also uneven and very clearly recorded in different places. The actors at times do not sound like they have any idea where to go with their next line, and that's not their fault. Acting in long distance is kind of like playing poker in the dark, you only hope you've got a better hand and you have no idea what the other person's face looks or what he's holding till the final hand is laid.
But the lack of intimacy in the lines could be mitigated if the lines overlapped a little. I just finished the latest Superman, and many of the characters simply wait until the other actor finishes all their lines before responding. This is ping-pong dialog, and doesn't sound at all like natural speech where people interrupt, cut off, and yell over top of someone else when things get tense.
And that too is a major problem. There's little tension in the production. The sound effects sound like they just appear, instead of produced by the scene. I listened to a fight scene between Lobo and Supergirl, expecting massive punches between these two near god-like individuals only to hear standard fight sounds, that reminded me of belly slaps instead of haymakers. If Supergirl gets hit by Lobo, I'm expecting there to be buildings she gets pounded through, or earthquake like shockwaves.
Not that this isn't easy to do with superheroes. Combat is one of the hardest type of scenes to get right, and I've only heard Kung Fu Action Theatre do an extremely good job at times letting me know what's going on. The pinnacle of superhero fights, for me at least, was Dirk Maggs Batman adventure Knightfall, but while that makes good inspiration, it is hardly expected.
What I do enjoy in the production is the music. Mr. Bridges has a good sense not only of what theme music works well, but also what works extremely well for mood music. That's a rare gift, and one that raises the audio drama.
Rating 2.5/5
Writing
The largest things missing in the writing I've heard, is tension. There are many scenes with characters that feel like padding. There is simply a lack of a strong through point to many of the plots. Superman seems plagued with many Mary and Barry Sue lines like, "Lois Lane is one of the world's greatest reporters". Perry White seems to tell Lois how great she is in every episode I've heard of Superman. My experience in a paper illuminated this praise from my Editor, "Well that didn't suck much."
Editors don't like to pat their reporters too hard on the back because they'll be looking for a raise if they do. Better to keep them hungry.
Keep the audience hungry. Add realistic tension between the characters. Make sure they don't get along well. Clark moons over Lois and Lois has only eyes for Superman, and even then she doesn't like to admit that to the general public. Drive your characters and plots like you're whipping a race horse to the finish. We've all read those comic books that spent much of the comic setting up a story. They were boring. I listened to an episode of Superman, that only brought Lobo out as a threat at the very end. Get tension out early and keep us wondering what's going to happen next. Revolve between groups of characters less, and focus on telling one story well in each episode. Too many subplots can have us lost. Again, this would be unfair to give an overall rating for the writing. But it needs some solid work in some places.
Additional Notes: The Eternal Dilemma
Pendant seems to have the opposite problems of Darker Projects. They produce far more shows on time, and presumably on budget, but their quality suffers. Which forces me to ask myself which I prefer more? Quality or Quantity?
It really is a hard choice because I really want to enjoy all the titles Pendant does. But in the end I choose quality. I'd rather Pendant took twice as long in their schedule to produce better quality scripts, acting, and production. I'd wait by my feed to ravenously devour those shows, instead of losing Pendant and coming back every once in a while with puppy dog hopefulness.
Over All Rating
Pendant Audio is an example where the sum of the parts make a greater whole. With all my stark criticisms and concerns about the productions, I love this company. I love it because I feel like I've grown up in Audio Drama with them. I just wish they'd mature faster with their tastes as I have. But they have fun making their shows, and I will continue to listen in hope.
Rating 3/5
.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


Some interesting comments - I'll bear them in mind when I'm listening to Star Trek: Defiant next time. Do you plan on reviewing individual series next or performers? Whilst the success of a production is a community effort and so stands on their group dynamics, there are performers who have done work across the range of different production groups whose work deserves to be brought to the public's attention
ReplyDeleteThank you for reading. There are a ton of companies that are out there right now and I'm going to try to hit them all to begin with.
ReplyDeleteSometimes that means single shows (like Wormwood and Art Lawful) which allows me to be very specific. Others like Pendant and Broken Sea have multiple shows and I can only give the most general reviews as to tone and major benefits and problems.
But... It has always been my intention to narrow my focus to series, even new releases and actors eventually. Ms. Ara Pelodi in another comment has asked for a review of her work, and I try to respond when people ask personally.
It would be neat to do a comparison of different shows. For example, Darker Projects versus Pendant versus Giant Gnome etc.. when it comes to Star Trek. But that would be a mammoth project as well and something down the line. It might save a couple separate reviews doing that... hm. I'll have to consider it.
Warmly,
~J. Snowe
I can only address the original work of Pendant as I don't do the fan fic ...but I am a big fan of their OUTV, The Kingery and,lately, "Red Sands Investigation".
ReplyDeleteNow, the sound issue that you address is really not an issue for me on these particular productions. A few of the others I've tried, namely "Dixie", did have some issue for me. But I wasn't certain if it was the overall comic book sort of intention that I didn't get into anyway..
I do think they also have several outstanding actors. A few fall flat but not bad enough to distract from the story; at least not for me.
And I do find these "original" stories very imaginative.
Several other things you note...the recording in different locations ...is duly apparent at times. With this I can agree. But I notice this sometimes on several other productions as well.
I suppose it takes a more careful ear with the editing.
And also the fight and action sequences..I will agree with your observation there also.
This may be, to me, their biggest flaw.
But I'm not sure if I can agree with your overall idea of slower production times to concentrate on quality. I think that serialized dramas are hard enough for a listener to follow on a monthly schedule.
Perhaps a better idea would be delegating different shows for different "seasons" so they would have fewer to concentrate on at a time.
They have a lot to keep up with.
And they're always right on time.
Overall, I do love Pendant and would like to see them thrive.
There's a lot of ground covered there and I'll agree that all of the points are valid to different degrees. I'll weigh in on ADR's side on the point about preferring to wait for quality though. As it is there is sometimes so long a wait between episodes that I need to re-listen to the earlier episode, but I would rather do this than be disappointed by what I hear. There are two options for resolution of this though...
ReplyDeleteComplete production of all or most of a season before releasing the first episode. Many production groups do this already
Shorten the length of the production so that you can release at shorter intervals - instead of 30 minutes once a month, release it as four 10 minute, weekly episodes.
K
I think you are both correct in that the best method is to complete a series before release. I would suggest that having six episodes "in the can" so to speak makes the most sense. Often shows can take a month to produce with actors, writers, and producers all getting together on their free time. Focus on getting ahead of the game. I believe Gregg Taylor does two shows a month and he records two shows a month. He is far ahead of the rest of the listeners just in case something occurs.
ReplyDeleteThis means more organization. Ongoing shows such as "Batman- Ace of Detectives" and the like would work best if they focused on maybe four episode series. Mr. Bridges seems to take on a lion's share of writing, and ideally it might be best if he spent more time overseeing the entire productions and less time trying to work in the trenches.
As for their original works, I look forward to listening to them and reviewing them as well.
When I do these reviews, I don't think about people who have a strong background in listening to audio drama but rather those people who are either new to the genre or occasional listeners. So I try to focus on the strengths and weaknesses with those in mind.
Certainly many of us who are fans of the medium will have a lot more patience.
Warmly,
~J. Snowe
fyi one of the things that might be why there's an overall 'tinny' or low-quality sound to the Pendant productions is that they are streamed online at 32kbps quality - admittedly extremely low. The majority of the shows (I believe) are mixed and mastered at 128 or higher. After 'seasons' of the fan shows are complete those episodes in the master quality are zipped up and offered as free downloads on the site. The originals are planned to have pay-for-CD releases, as the first seasons of Dixie and The Kingery have done so far.
ReplyDeleteI myself mixed the first two "Dixie Stenberg" seasons at 224k and seasons three and four at 320.
But that's just overall mix quality. Acting and such is another can of qagh... :)
DJFanboy.. Thanks for the extra information. That's very helpful.
ReplyDeleteWhy not release the shows at 128k? The quality is much better and still better quality can be held back for purchase then?
Warmly,
~J. Snowe
Originally it was a question of server space, working on a budget and not wanting their streams to go overboard. But now that's not so much.
ReplyDeleteIt's a discussion the upper-ups at Pendant have been having for some time, tho I don't know where they are at the moment with that decision. Certainly having 128k eps would serve Pendant better with the 'quality' reviews we've been getting.
I only just became aware of this review today, so please pardon my delay in responding. Thanks for the time you put into the review.
ReplyDeleteThere were a few misconceptions you seem to have, though, so I'm going to try to clear those up.
First, I don't write everything. :)
We have a dozen monthly shows and I only write two of them (and I oversee a team of writers on a third). I did write the Bond and Indy features as well, but those were years ago. We have a whole stable of talented writers working on our shows.
"If Supergirl gets hit by Lobo, I'm expecting there to be buildings she gets pounded through, or earthquake like shockwaves."
The problem there is not every fight every superpowered person has can do that. It gets old fast (especially when you've got episode numbers in the sixties). You've got to vary it up. Sometimes the fights are small and tease you, and sometimes they are quite big and there are shockwaves and buildings destroyed. It all depends on what the story calls for.
If you want a monster superhero fight, check out Superman 50 or, in two months, Superman 65. I love huge fights, but you just can't realistically do that every time there's a fight IMO.
"Mr. Bridges has a good sense not only of what theme music works well, but also what works extremely well for mood music. "
I can't take credit for that. I don't direct or mix any of our shows (except our weekly news shows), and haven't for years now. For as deep and diverse as our writers are, our directors are even moreso. Any music choices you like, all credit goes to them, not me. I'm a schlub of a director. :)
"Clark moons over Lois and Lois has only eyes for Superman, and even then she doesn't like to admit that to the general public."
Actually Lois and Clark are married in TLSOK, so she does quite admit that to the general public (and has since 1994 ;)
"I listened to an episode of Superman, that only brought Lobo out as a threat at the very end."
Again, that's a stylistic choice. It was his first-ever appearance in the show. I don't think you'd advocate a character who never appeared before simply showing up and getting into a huge fight instantly, but perhaps you would. My goal there was to surprise the audience with his appearance (which it seemed to do). In subsequent episodes the tension is built, small fights lead to bigger fights and then... well, in two months you get Superman 65.
If it didn't work for you then perhaps my intention failed, but I still think it was a better way to introduce the character.
The issue with multiple story threads is something you'll find in all of our shows. If you only listened to one episode I can see your confusion, but it's important to remember that these *are* serials and are written and intended as such.
The only other comment I have is your "quality" issue, which as DJFanboy said is because our shows are released at 32kbps by design (but you are more than welcome to get free CD-quality versions in season-long zip files for nearly every show, and CD box sets for others... all available right on the website).
As Seth said, initially this was due to server space and bandwidth issues. Those things are no longer an issue for us, and we've thought about releasing the full-quality versions in the main podcast feed. But every time we do, the overwhelming majority of people we talk to about it say they want us to keep the web-quality versions. They're a much faster download and people seem to really like that, especially knowing they can download the CD quality versions after every season (or purchase a CD set for original shows to help support us).
I suggest giving some of the CD-quality zip packs a try. :)
Thanks again for the review!
Thank-you for the detailed response Mr. Bridges. I do appreciate getting the background information. It's informative and, as you said, clears up some misconceptions.
ReplyDeleteI have to say, my responses seem a little muted at times because I am quite pleasantly surprised at the number of people who read this blog.
My intention, as I've said before, is two fold.
First and foremost, it is to inform the public of what is available, and what they are effectively "stepping into" while listening.
It would do nobody good if every show they listened to they expected BBC quality.
Understanding the various characters of each audio drama company, in my mind at least, informs the viewers of what to expect.
Knowing that the quality is a little less (but faster) helps gauges someone's expectations.
Secondly, I spend quite a lot of time listening to audio drama, and knowing now that I am writing up notes I take notes.
While I freely admit that it is certainly not as much time taken in producing these shows by any means, it still represents a significant portion of my time.
I do it as a listener who wants to pass feedback to the people who operate in this medium I love as much as inform new listeners.
If they take my reviews to heart as a genuine concern, then that is what is intended.
If they read into it some kind of flame war or slight, then I'm afraid they've missed the point.
I thank you for taking the time, and understanding the spirit in which the review is given.
I look forward to going back into your voluminous history and discovering more of what you have pointed out.
Warmly,
~J. Snowe
"Understanding the various characters of each audio drama company, in my mind at least, informs the viewers of what to expect."
ReplyDeleteI agree completely, which is why it's vital to be sure you don't mischaracterize them. Pendant, for example, does not produce shows at "poor quality". We release them at a web-quality for faster download and then release full cd-quality shows after. And all that information is right up on our site.
I think it's just important to be sure you've got all the facts before you make generalizations about a company.
"If they take my reviews to heart as a genuine concern, then that is what is intended.
If they read into it some kind of flame war or slight, then I'm afraid they've missed the point."
I certainly haven't taken it that way, but if others have it may be because you might have again made somewhat sweeping generalizations without enough experience with a company to make an informed decision.
Thinking I write every show, for example, when we have a dozen monthly shows and the credits are right on the website, is a mistake that could have been cleared up with two minutes of fact-checking.
Complaining about a superhero fight as being "not big enough" while failing to listen to more than one or two episodes (or to judge it as one episode of a serial as opposed to a stand-alone story) convey the message that you're either not paying close enough attention or aren't concerned with trying to be accurate.
Especially when you mention those things (isolated incidents from one show among a dozen plus) and treat them as if they are indicative of every episode of that show, much less every show in the entire company.
But I'm glad you've taken my comments in the way they were intended. It's certainly not a flame or any sort of slight, I'm merely reviewing your review, as it were, and pointing out spots for improvement.
Best of luck on future reviews.
The focus here seems to be on Pendant's "Superman, The Man of Steel" serial and unfortunately I can't comment because is one I've never followed.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Jeffery as regards the fact that you need to mix-up your fight/battle sound effects but I think the editor should focus on creating a "sound-scape" - not so much paint an aural picture but giving the dialog a background within which it can come alive. I think of audio drama characters as the subjects of a painting, and the sound effects and music as the background, the landscape, in fact the very texture of the canvas itself.
To my mind dialogue is the meat-and-potatoes of audio drama but sound effects and *especially* the music are the trimmings, the ranch dressing, the flowers on the table, the view out of the restaurant window... The things that make the meal memorable by complementing it and bringing out its finer points.
Perhaps DJFanboy or Jefferey could point out something in the way of a soundscape that they are particularly proud of? I remember Jeffrey doing a jail cell scene in Star Trek Defiant that was particularly powerful although for the life of me I can't remember the details. - K
PS gotta catch up on Dixie I quite enjoyed it
Any jail scenes in Defiant weren't mixed by me. Those would have been done by Chris Brittain, I believe.
ReplyDeleteI can also quite assure you none of my mixing was on the caliber of the stuff our other directors are doing. Again, it's not my strong suit.
I do agree with what you've said, though. Radio drama IS dialogue, the rest is just details to pretty it up. Interestingly I've recently started branching out, though, and wrote an episode of Kingery coming out at the end of April that actually is nothing BUT sound effects.
I wanted to see if I could write a scene that still advanced the story without dialogue, and to the credit of Perry Whittle and Christopher Stadther, they pulled it off. But it's certainly not something I'd do in every episode or even more than once in a blue moon.
Thanks for the compliment on Dixie, glad you enjoyed it. It'll be ending later this year, actually, with episode 50.
Er, to clarify, there's ONE SMALL SCENE that's nothing but sound effects. Not an entire episode.
ReplyDeleteEgad.
Thanks so much for the clarifications Mr. Bridges, and Kirok.
ReplyDeleteI am confused as to where my commented response was originally. I did mention that I had listened to several different productions. Although I didn't go back into three or four episodes of each. While I can understand where that is somewhat unfair to an ongoing series, I can also see where a new listener would do the exact thing. Sample an episode and decide whether they wanted to listen to the rest or not. It is a truism that episodes, regardless of their run, should be able to stand on their own.
It is true that Mr. Bridges does not write all of the shows, however, many of the shows I listened to he did.
Unfortunately, any review that takes on such voluminous work is bound to be fraught with errors. So I can only pledge to try to continue to improve as I narrow my gaze upon each series.
I look forward to do so!
Warmly,
~J. Snowe